© 2024 Michigan State University Board of Trustees
Public Media from Michigan State University
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Mubarak's Case: What's The Best Approach With Ex-Dictators?

Former Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak was released from prison on Thursday and put under house arrest at a military hospital.
Amr Abdallah Dalsh
Former Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak was released from prison on Thursday and put under house arrest at a military hospital.

When Hosni Mubarak was whisked out of prison by helicopter on Thursday, he did not become a free man. The former Egyptian leader, 85, was taken to a military hospital in Cairo, where he's under house arrest and still faces criminal charges.

But to many, the move was highly symbolic, the latest sign that the 2011 revolution is being rolled back and that the country's future is growing messier and more complicated by the day.

Mubarak's fate remains politically sensitive, potentially explosive and may not be resolved for months or even years. The case also raises a difficult and recurring question: What's the best way to deal with current and former dictators?

The Arab uprisings offer examples that run the gamut.

The Quick Getaway

In Tunisia's revolution in January 2011, the first major upheaval of the Arab Spring, President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali made a quick getaway to Saudi Arabia on a plane that was reportedly loaded with gold bars.

He was convicted of embezzlement in absentia, but now spends his days quietly in Saudi Arabia. Many critics say Ben Ali and his associates got off far too easy and that justice has not been served.

But there's the counterargument that his swift departure marked a conclusive end to his regime and helped clear the way for the country to remake itself.

In this line of reasoning, a dictator should be encouraged to go into exile whenever possible. He may not have to account for his sins, but his departure will allow the country to look forward, rather than backward.

Tunisia is still struggling amid political quarreling and periodic political killings. But there's no prospect of Ben Ali's return, and Tunisia has fared better than other Arab states that have gone through upheavals in the past two years.

Stand And Fight

At the other extreme are dictators who dug in their heels.

In Libya, Moammar Gadhafi unleashed his army in the face of an uprising and immediately plunged the country into civil war. Even after he was driven from the capital, Tripoli, in August 2011, Gadhafi remained in Libya and sought to rally his supporters. He was captured and killed two months later.

Gadhafi may be gone, but many armed groups that emerged during the civil war are still roaming the streets and contributing to the country's instability.

Conditions are far more dire in Syria, where President Bashar Assad remains in power despite two years of civil war and some 100,000 dead.

Assad's regime faces a new round of international outrage following accusations that his forces carried out a chemical weapons attack near the capital, Damascus, on Wednesday, inflicting mass casualties.

The government, which denies using chemical weapons, has been ostracized by the West and much of the international community, but Assad does not appear to be in imminent danger of ouster.

Step Down, But Not Out

Mubarak relinquished power in February 2011 after 18 days of protests that included violent clashes that left hundreds dead.

However, when he stepped down, he didn't leave Egypt, opting for the Red Sea resort of Sharm el-Sheik. This led the country to confront Mubarak's legacy in the courts, and he's still facing multiple charges, from corruption to complicity in the 2011 killings of demonstrators.

While he's now been cleared in one case, he could be back in court as soon as Sunday, according to reports from Cairo.

So what would be better for Egypt right now: lengthy court cases that scrutinize Mubarak's most controversial actions, or a quiet exile in a far away land?

And then there's Assad. Would his departure into a safe exile be acceptable if it helped bring an end to the country's savage bloodletting?

Let us know what you think.

Copyright 2021 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

Greg Myre is a national security correspondent with a focus on the intelligence community, a position that follows his many years as a foreign correspondent covering conflicts around the globe.
Journalism at this station is made possible by donors who value local reporting. Donate today to keep stories like this one coming. It is thanks to your generosity that we can keep this content free and accessible for everyone. Thanks!