Under Trump, SEC Enforcement Of Insider Trading Dropped To Lowest Point In Decades

Aug 14, 2020

The government agency responsible for policing Wall Street brought the fewest number of insider trading cases in decades, according to the most recent available data.

That decline came just before the COVID-19 pandemic hit. The Securities and Exchange Commission now warns that the pandemic has created wild swings in the market and more opportunities for insider trading.

NPR reviewed data from the 1980s through last year and found that under the Trump administration, the SEC brought just 32 insider trading enforcement actions in 2019, the lowest number since 1996.

The SEC charged 46 defendants as part of those cases. That was the lowest number of defendants in insider trading cases since Ronald Reagan was president, and about half of the annual average over the last three decades. The decline has alarmed experts and advocates, who worry that flagrant illegal trading may go unchecked.

Loading...

In a statement, a spokesperson for the SEC called insider trading enforcement a "core component" of the commission's work, saying, "We continue to vigorously pursue insider trading cases against individuals and companies."

Despite a 35-day government shutdown, the overall number of SEC enforcement actions increased in 2019, largely due to a crackdown on other wrongdoing, including alleged abuses by investment advisers. But as other enforcement areas grew, insider trading made up less than 4% of the commission's enforcement work that year, another decades-long low.

The SEC has still brought high-profile insider trading cases in the Trump era. In 2018, for example, the commission charged then-U.S. Rep. Chris Collins, R-N.Y. Collins served on the board of an Australian biotech company and tipped off his son, so they could unload stock before a bad announcement led to a sell-off. Overall, 2017 and 2018 were much closer to historic averages of insider trading enforcement. But the SEC spokesperson did not address why enforcement appeared to drop so dramatically in 2019.

U.S. Sen. Richard Burr, R-N.C., is under FBI investigation and has faced bipartisan condemnation for making major stock trades at the same time he was getting private government briefings on COVID-19. Eastman Kodak is also under SEC investigation and has announced its own "internal review" after an unusual amount of trading activity the day before it announced it would be receiving $765 million in government loans. That loan is now on hold, as the government agency making the loan said "allegations of wrongdoing raise serious concerns." Burr and Kodak have denied any wrongdoing.

Despite those recent cases, the overall numbers are clearly down. "You can't do every case," said Doug Davison, a former SEC enforcement supervisor. But a lack of resources doesn't explain the drop: Adjusted for inflation, the SEC's budget has roughly quadrupled in the last three decades.

And while insider trading can be difficult to detect, there's no evidence that 2019 was simply a more honest year on Wall Street.

"That seems extremely unlikely," said Brandon Cline, a finance professor at Mississippi State University. "I don't think that human behavior has shifted."

Instead, experts and former SEC attorneys said, the drop in insider trading enforcement likely reflects the choices of its leadership. Under Chairman Jay Clayton, the SEC has largely focused on protecting individual investors from shady advisers, Ponzi schemers or con artists. Clayton likes to say he advocates on behalf of Main Street investors and "Mr. and Mrs. 401(k)."

Loading...

"They've been focused on more black-and-white wrongdoing," Davison said. The SEC has also added more resources to look into cyber-related misconduct, such as hackers stealing and trading based off of company secrets, or issues with cryptocurrency.

Those areas are important, as underscored by a major hack of the SEC's own systems in 2016. But the shift in priorities has some experts and advocates worried.

Research by Cline and his colleague, Valeriya Posylnaya of the University of Minnesota Duluth, indicates that when the SEC aggressively polices insider trading, it does deter illegal activity. If executives see a major figure such as Martha Stewart get hauled to court, as she did when she faced a criminal indictment and SEC charges for insider trading in 2003, they tend to think twice before acting on inside information.

And the reverse is true, Cline said: If enforcement drops, "we should then observe more insider trading in years to come."

The shift in priorities and the significant drop in insider trading investigations in 2019 send a terrible message to Wall Street, advocates said.

"That means they're not trying," said Bartlett Naylor, a financial policy advocate with the left-leaning watchdog group Public Citizen. "That means they told the cops to go play canasta instead of doing their job."

Critics inside and outside government see plenty of work to do. The SEC's investigation into Kodak has already attracted scrutiny from House Democrats, who have launched their own investigation. Previously, Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., also called for an SEC investigation into trades of defense stocks before the U.S. assassination of Iranian Gen. Qassem Soleimani, and whether President Trump may have alerted members of his Mar-a-Lago club in advance of the strike.

The pandemic and the government's financial rescue packages have also created additional opportunities for illegal trading activity.

"The pharmaceutical industry generally is very susceptible to insider trading," said Eric Chaffee, a law professor at the University of Toledo and editor of the Securities Law Prof Blog.

"Getting approval from the [Food and Drug Administration] can be very determinative to whether a company's fortunes rise or fall," Chaffee said, and announcements related to COVID-19 vaccine development can dramatically affect the market.

In March, the co-directors of the SEC's enforcement division issued a statement warning that "in these dynamic circumstances, corporate insiders are regularly learning new material nonpublic information that may hold an even greater value than under normal circumstances."

Members of Congress have been closely scrutinizing Clayton's record. Trump recently tapped Clayton to take over as the top federal prosecutor in New York. In the process, the administration pushed out the U.S. attorney for the Southern District of New York, Geoffrey S. Berman, who had investigated allies of the president.

And unchecked insider trading can dramatically undermine people's confidence in the financial system, said Urska Velikonja, a Georgetown University law professor who has closely studied the SEC's enforcement data.

When company executives and politicians appear to engage in flagrant insider trading, Velikonja said, "that's where you start entering the very dangerous terrain, and people look at this and say, 'This is all rigged.' "

If left to run rampant, she said, "it does have the potential to unsettle political systems."

Copyright 2020 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

SARAH MCCAMMON, HOST:

Since the pandemic hit, financial markets have crashed and soared. That volatility has meant more opportunities for insider trading, using inside information to profit in the stock market, which is illegal. NPR has found the Trump administration has brought the fewest number of insider trading cases in decades. Here's NPR investigative correspondent Tom Dreisbach.

TOM DREISBACH, BYLINE: Think insider trading, maybe you think Martha Stewart...

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

UNIDENTIFIED REPORTER #1: Martha Stewart was indicted on criminal charges relating to an insider trading scandal that began more than a year ago.

DREISBACH: ...Or the guy who inspired the phrase greed is good.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

UNIDENTIFIED REPORTER #2: Ivan Boesky, a leading Wall Street takeover specialist, agreed to pay a record $100 million penalty for insider trading abuses.

DREISBACH: Those were both big years for insider trading cases. 2019 was not. We looked at more than three decades of data from the Securities and Exchange Commission, the government's top financial cop. And last year, the SEC brought 32 insider trading cases, the fewest since 1996. Often more than one person is charged in each case, and in 2019, the SEC charged 46 defendants, the fewest since Ronald Reagan was president. In an average year, it usually charges double that number. So was Wall Street just more ethical last year?

BRANDON CLINE: That seems extremely unlikely.

DREISBACH: That's Brandon Cline. He's a finance professor at Mississippi State University. And he says in any given year, the government is actually just scratching the surface of illegal activity.

CLINE: They willfully admit that they only catch a very small portion of those that are engaging in illegal insider trading.

DREISBACH: The SEC is a lot bigger than it was in the 1980s or '90s, but there's never enough time to go after every bit of financial wrongdoing. Here's Doug Davison. He used to actually do this enforcement.

DOUG DAVISON: There's a lot of things going on. You got a certain amount of resources. You can't do every case.

DREISBACH: So it's all about choices. The Trump appointee that runs the SEC is Jay Clayton. Before entering government, he was a longtime corporate lawyer. Under Clayton's leadership, the SEC has focused on policing two areas, cyber misconduct and protecting Main Street investors from financial con artists. Here he is in 2017.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

JAY CLAYTON: As I say it when I walk the halls of the agency, how does what we propose to do affect the long-term interests of Mr. and Ms. 401(k)?

DREISBACH: And last year, the SEC brought a lot more cases going after shady investment advisers and returning money to victims who got defrauded. Despite a government shutdown, overall enforcement cases were up. But at the same time, there were fewer insider trading cases. Research has indicated that aggressive enforcement of those cases actually does deter insider trading. If a CEO sees someone like Martha Stewart get hauled to court, the theory goes, they might think twice.

Bartlett Naylor, an advocate with the left-leaning group Public Citizen, says the fact that the commission brought fewer cases sends a terrible message to Wall Street.

BARTLETT NAYLOR: That means they are not trying. That means they told the cops to go play canasta instead of do their job.

DREISBACH: The SEC itself acknowledges that market volatility during the pandemic can make insider trading more tempting. A big announcement about, say, a vaccine or a government loan can dramatically change a company's fortunes. Urska Velikonja of Georgetown University says that when people get away with insider trading, it underscores a sense that the stock market is just for the well-connected.

URSKA VELIKONJA: It does, you know, have the potential to unsettle political systems as well in the long run.

DREISBACH: Because it just feels fundamentally unfair.

VELIKONJA: Because it's just - this is fundamentally unfair. It's all rigged. Burn the house down, and start from scratch.

DREISBACH: We still don't have final numbers for how much enforcement the SEC has done this year. In a statement, a spokesperson said vigorous insider trading enforcement remains a core component of the commission's work. But they did not address the overall drop in numbers. We know it is currently investigating Kodak, as well as U.S. Sen. Richard Burr of North Carolina. Both have denied wrongdoing. Those investigations can take a long time. So far, no charges have been filed. Tom Dreisbach, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.